Comparison Between Radical Esophagectomy and Definitive Chemoradiotherapy in Patients with Clinical T1bN0M0 Esophageal Cancer

Masaaki Motoori MD, Masahiko Yano MD, Ryu Ishihara MD, Sachiko Yamamoto MD, Yoshifumi Kawaguchi MD, Koji Tanaka MD, Kentaro Kishi MD, Isao Miyashiro MD, Yoshiyuki Fujiwara MD, Tatsushi Shingai MD, Shingo Noura MD, Masayuki Ohue MD, Hiroaki Ohigashi MD, Satoaki Nakamura MD, Osamu Ishikawa MD
Gastrointestinal Oncology
Online First ™ - February , 2012

View full article HTML | View full article PDF | Download Citation

Abstract

Background

Esophagectomy remains the mainstay treatment for clinical T1bN0M0 esophageal cancer because pathologic lymph node metastases in these patients are not negligible. Recently, chemoradiotherapy (CRT), which can preserve the esophagus, has been reported to be a promising therapeutic alternative to esophagectomy. However, to our knowledge, no comparative studies of esophagectomy and CRT have been reported in clinical T1bN0M0 esophageal cancer.

Methods

A total of 173 patients with clinical T1bN0M0 squamous cell carcinoma of the thoracic esophagus were enrolled in this study, 102 of whom were treated with radical esophagectomy (S group) and 71 with definitive CRT (CRT group). Treatment results of both groups were retrospectively compared.

Results

No statistically significant difference was found in overall survival, but the S group displayed significantly better progression-free survival than the CRT group. Disease recurrence was observed in 12 S group patients and 20 CRT group patients. The incidence of distant recurrence was similar, while local recurrence and lymph node recurrence were significantly more frequent in the CRT group. In the S group, 20 patients had pathologic lymph node metastasis. The progression-free survival of patients with pathologic lymph node metastasis did not differ from those without nodal metastasis. In the CRT group, local recurrence could be controlled by salvage esophagectomy, but treatment results of lymph node recurrence were poor; only 4 of 12 patients with lymph node recurrences were cured.

Conclusions

Selection of patients at high risk of pathologic lymph node metastasis is essential when formulating treatment decisions for clinical T1bN0M0 esophageal cancers.

Go to Issue Contents